More
    HomeMilitaryUnveiling the 2018 Pentagon Fly-Off: F-35 vs. A-10

    Unveiling the 2018 Pentagon Fly-Off: F-35 vs. A-10

    Published on

    spot_img

    A concealed report from a 2018 Pentagon fly-off, which compared the F-35 Lightning II and the A-10 Thunderbolt II in their designated combat roles, has been dramatically unveiled.

    F-35 Lightning II” by Chad Horwedel is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

    Released following a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request, the document illustrates the complexities and constraints of modern air support without declaring a definitive victor, suggesting instead that a combination of the F-35’s advanced technology and the A-10’s robust capabilities could offer the best solution in combat scenarios.

    UK F-35B Lightning II” by Defence Images is licensed under CC BY-NC 2.0

    The fly-off, conducted to determine if the F-35 could effectively replace the A-10’s traditional roles, particularly focused on Close Air Support (CAS), Forward Air Controller Airborne (FAC(A)), and Combat Search and Rescue (CSAR). Despite the ambitious intent behind the comparison, the results, heavily redacted for national security reasons, left no clear impression of superiority for either aircraft.

    EGYPT — An A-10 Thunderbolt II from the 188th Fighter Wing, Ft. Smith, Ark., flies off the wing of a KC-135 Stratotanker assigned to the 100th Air Refueling Wing, RAF Mildenhall, England, during a coronet mission Oct. 12, 2012. A coronet is when an aerial refueling tanker escorts fighters over long distances, regularly topping off their fuel tanks along the way. (U.S. Air Force photo/Staff Sgt. Austin M. May)

    It appeared the tests did not fully realize the envisioned head-to-head matchup, especially considering the absence of ground troops, which prevented a genuine assessment of the F-35’s support capabilities in an engaged-combat context.

    DAYTON, Ohio — Fairchild Republic A-10A Thunderbolt II at the National Museum of the United States Air Force. (U.S. Air Force photo)

    The secrecy surrounding the report – it wasn’t written until four years after the tests and only disclosed following legal action – fueled speculation that the results were not in favor of the F-35.

    ROYAL AIR FORCE MIDENHALL, England — An A-10 Thunderbolt II rolls to mark a target with simulated M-156 white phosphorus rockets as part of an aerial demonstration held here. The demonstration was for the 44 visiting U.S. civic, business, and industry leaders on the 2003 Joint Civilian Orientation Course. (U.S. Air Force photo by Tech. Sgt. Michael D. Morford)

    If the fifth-generation stealth jet had indeed outperformed the A-10, it stands to reason such findings would have been heralded rather than obscured.

    An A-10 Thunderbolt II flies a combat mission over Afghanistan. A-10s provide close-air support and employ a wide variety of conventional munitions, including general purpose bombs, cluster bombs units and laser guided bombs. (U.S. Air Force photo/Staff Sgt. Aaron Allmon)

    As POGO asserts, that the “results were apparently not what the Air Force’s leaders expected, because they fought to hide them completely for years.”

    OVER THE MEDITERRANEAN SEA — An A-10 Thunderbolt II from the 104th Fighter Wing, Barnes Municipal Airport, Westfield Mass., Massachusetts Air National Guard, banks while flying accross the Mediterranean Sea enroute to a forward operating base. (U.S. Air Force photo by Master Sgt. Mark Bucher)

    From what could be discerned in the unredacted sections, the A-10C demonstrated its well-known strengths.

    Designed with a large ammunition capacity to support ground forces, its ability to carry 16 GBU-39 small diameter bombs and deliver 1,350 rounds from its GAU-8 cannon starkly contrasts with the F-35A’s capacity for only eight bombs and 181 rounds from its less accurate 25mm cannon.

    Tactics allowed A-10C pilots to fly closer to targets, leveraging the aircraft’s armored protection and redundancy to withstand damage – a clear advantage over the F-35A’s reliance on high-altitude flight and stealth.

    The F-35’s challenges extend beyond the fly-off. A September 2023 Government Accountability Office report painted a grim picture of the F-35 fleet’s readiness rates, with a full mission capable rate of less than 50%. This raises concerns about the F-35’s ability to maintain a consistent presence in the skies compared to the rugged and reliable A-10.

    In an enlightening yet redacted glimpse into pilot preferences, the report mentioned both F-35A and A-10C pilots acknowledging the potential synergies of operating in tandem during contested missions.

    An A-10 Thunderbolt II flies a combat mission over Afghanistan. A-10s provide close-air support and employ a wide variety of conventional munitions, including general purpose bombs, cluster bombs units and laser guided bombs. (U.S. Air Force photo/Staff Sgt. Aaron Allmon)

    It intimates a recognition that combining the F-35’s advanced systems with the A-10’s proven capabilities could enhance mission outcomes – a far cry from the initial Air Force narrative of the F-35 as a solitary successor to the A-10.

    “A frequent comment by both F-35A and A-10C pilots during debriefings was the synergies that would occur if A-10C formations operated with F-35A escort during contested CSAR missions. This would combine the strengths of both platforms while mitigating their limitations to improve the likelihood of mission success,” the report states.

    Despite the substantial obfuscation of the report’s content, the underlying message is clear: no solitary winner emerged from the 2018 fly-off. As the Air Force continues to plan the A-10’s retirement, this report adds a layer of complexity to the decision, suggesting that the future of effective combat air support may well rest on the wings of both these diverse aircraft working in concert rather than in competition.

    Relevant articles:
    F-35 and A-10 Close Air Support Flyoff Report, Project on Government Oversight (POGO)
    The Pentagon’s Secret Fly, Popular Mechanics
    Air Force finally reveals a little bit about how the F-35 stacks up in providing close air support, federalnewsnetwork.com

    Latest articles

    F-15 Eagle’s Dominance: The Untold Story of Its First Combat Triumph

    In the annals of military aviation history, few aircraft have earned a reputation quite...

    Uncovering WWII Bombs: Germany’s Continuing Battle with Hidden Threats

    Every year, German land produces a chilling crop: roughly 2,000 tons of unexploded World...

    Clacton Spear Discovery Reshapes Early Hominid Hunting and Cognition Understanding

    The recent focus on the Clacton Spear, an old wooden object discovered in Clacton-on-Sea,...

    FN Five-seveN MRD: A New Era in Precision Handguns

    The FN Five-seveN has stood out in the modern firearms landscape for years, known...

    More like this

    F-15 Eagle’s Dominance: The Untold Story of Its First Combat Triumph

    In the annals of military aviation history, few aircraft have earned a reputation quite...

    Uncovering WWII Bombs: Germany’s Continuing Battle with Hidden Threats

    Every year, German land produces a chilling crop: roughly 2,000 tons of unexploded World...

    Clacton Spear Discovery Reshapes Early Hominid Hunting and Cognition Understanding

    The recent focus on the Clacton Spear, an old wooden object discovered in Clacton-on-Sea,...